High Definition Shopping
A simple trip to any big box electronics retailer will allow anyone to experience what I have. I've visited Best Buy, Sears and Circuit City, and their TV displays all run way too similarly. They have a handful of aisles with their sets side by side and on shelves. The largest, and most expensive plasmas are on the outer walls. The sales folk are often not too knowledgeable. No, make that they barely know the manufacturer, and nothing much beyond that. The quickest way to scurry them is to ask the screen resolution, or if it has a QAM cable tuner. These types of technical questions send them for the hills, and I haven't encountered any of them that could provide ready answers to gear that they should be expert in.
The primary goal of venturing into a store to buy a television is to be able to compare the pictures side by side between the sets one is considering. Most of the stores show either a live HD signal, or HD content from a looped disc, although at times the signal does look less than hi def at some stores (Best Buy has the best loop IMHO). Adding to the difficulties of the comparison is that the adjustment, or lack of thereof, of the sets. Of the retailers, Wal-Mart's gear was the worst adjusted as no set was set up well, and they all were either too red or way too green. Of course with folks fiddling with them all day I’m sure it’s an uphill battle, but even sets that looked fine in other stores look like a piece of junk at Wal-Mart’s display.
A TV's remote is an essential component of the total package. As part of the decision making process, it’s a good idea to be able to handle the remote, and to see how comfortable it sits in the hand. After all, most of us do a lot of channel flipping, and any aficionado will agree that not all remotes are created equal. Unfortunately for us, it’s often a big secret as to what remote will come with the TV as they are not on display. I suppose they keep them in the back for when they sell the floor model, but that doesn’t help the would be purchaser.
Through this whole process, I’ve learned a few things that I’d like to share as some suggestions for purchasing that new high definition television.
1-Do Your Homework
I really mean homework, as in done at home before going to the store. It’s essential that you decide on the type of technology you’d like beforehand, as it only gets more confusing in the store with the audio turned up from all of the sets, and the stereos. Personally, I wouldn’t buy an old style tube television no matter how cheap it is as even with a digital tuner, they aren’t capable of displaying high def (by definition, >480 lines of resolution). The next technology to be avoided is the DLP. These use a spinning disc and a light to create the picture. While again they cost less, and the cabinets are smaller than traditional TV’s, I think the pictures always look muddy, dark, and lack sharpness and crispness. That leaves plasma vs. LCD (at least until energy efficient OLED’s and super sharp “laser TV’s” debut). If you’re going really big than it’s plasma, and for smaller sets it’s LCD. Around 36” - 40” is where the technology goes either way. I’m personally biased for LCD as it is more energy efficient, has less screen burn in issues, and perhaps will have greater longevity, but you’ll have to come to that conclusion for yourself.
2-Grab a Tape Measure
Some of these new TV’s are quite large. Just because it is a flat panel, it still has a certain height and width. Most of us don’t live in a sports stadium so we do need to consider the size of the set. Aren’t all of these size specs on the web? While it is true that many manufacturer and retail sites do provide the measurements of the TV, in many cases they are wrong. For example, many of them state the height, but don’t mention that this is without the stand attached. Far better to find out now that we don’t have room for it, than to get it home and find out that it won’t clear the top of your media cabinet. Not to mention that some of the lesser manufacturers don’t have any size measurements at all.
3-Read the Manual
While it’s the exceptional salesperson that really knows the televisions, all of the essential specs are in the owner’s manual. While the stores don’t have this available, this is where a little internet surfing can yield a big dividend. Head on over to the manufacturer’s website and look for the downloadable PDF of the manual. After a sizable download, we can now know the screen resolution, the remote control layout, how the set handles letterbox films, and the menu screens and capabilities. Now we can better tell if the set has all the function needed to earn a place in our home, or it’s just another pretty budget box and not really a bargain after all.
4-All the Right Connections
It’s good to figure out what else you’ll be connecting to the TV, and make sure it has the correct jacks to connect everything. Take up a tally of video game systems, VCR’s, DVD players and recorders, media extenders and DVR’s and make sure there will be a spot for everything to plug into the set.. Also, don’t forget to take into account a video camera, or even a digital camera that will benefit from front mounted inputs to hook up easily on a temporary basis. Some of the better sets do have more inputs, and time spent now will avoid the perpetual game of unplugging and plugging gear in every time you want to use it. Don’t forget that times change, and make sure there is at least one extra input in case something else comes along that needs the TV. Also, look for a set that has a VGA input for a computer as this will allow it to be used as a computer monitor.
5-Check the Tuner
The tuner is less of an issue these days than before, but there are still plenty of analog only devices out there still sitting on shelves waiting to be sold. Ideally, the device should come with an analog tuner, NTSC, a digital tuner, ATSC, and a cable tuner, QAM. This way, no matter what signal source the TV is hooked into, it will be able to tune into the broadcast. The manual, and the product box are two good places to check the tuner situation of a particular TV.
6-Comparison Shop
After we’ve decided on a set, then is the time to get the best deal on it. Head online to retailers such as NewEgg.com, Amazon.com, and Buy.com. Also don’t forget that CC and BB sometimes have different models or prices on the web than they do in their retail stores. Also, recall that the majority of TV’s are sold from Thanksgiving to Super Bowl Sunday, so that’s when the best deals are to be found. Don’t forget to check out the local circulars for these sales as well which often rotate manufacturers on sale week by week.
7-One Way Money
Before plunking down that credit card, verify what the return policy of the retailer is. The 15% restocking fee, even if the set is broken out of the box, can become hundreds of dollars on a 60” plasma screen. While the usual is that if the set is dysfunctional and can be exchanged for the same model without charge, getting the dough back completely to buy a different model is not an option. Make sure to verify what model you want, and be darn sure before the purchase as it becomes a done deal rather quickly. Also, be aware that Wal-Mart, and most price clubs will allow a return without the restocking fee so if they have the model desired this should be the preferred retailer for the purchase.
8-Don’t Be A Sucker
Finally, don’t be too eager to sign onto the extended warranty plan. They’re usually expensive, and the retailers love them because they pad their profit margins heftily. Don’t forget that if the purchase is charged to a gold credit card, that both Visa and Master Card will double the manufacturer’s warranty- up to one year. The only proof required is the receipt, and the credit card statement showing the purchase.
--Jonas
Labels: Digital Television, retail, Television
2 Comments:
From Gyro-Gearloose:
Some good advice but a few comments.
First, as regards CRT based displays. In fact, not even plasma can stand up to a well made CRT based display. The CRT is what the LCD and plasma manufacturers attempt to emulate. CRTs have better contrast, a greater viewing angle, better blacks, and are perfectly capable of displaying 1080i or greater in native format. The biggest drawbacks to large CRT displays are size and weight. My 30" CRT based display does 1080i native and looks just fine. But the damned thing weighs 140 lbs! Imagine what a 42" or a 60" CRT based display would weigh?
Plasmas, in my opinion, look better than LCDs but they generate a lot of heat, use a lot of electricity, and also generate a great deal of RF noise. If you like to listen to the radio, or happen to be an amateur radio operator, beware, plasmas are noisy.
The quality of LCD displays vary widely. Always look at something with a lot of fast motion when evaluating an LCD display. This is where they will fall apart if they are going to disappoint.
I agree with you about the big box stores. I found the most knowledgeable sales folks at Costco of all places. At my Costco, the sales person new the stock and could answer any question a prospective buyer might ask. It was quite refreshing. Don't know if all Costcos are like that.
I think you will disappointed with a 26" display. My 30" set is the
minimum I would consider for HD or 16x9 SD viewing. Cabinetry is a problem as entertainment furniture has not kept up with the switch to wide screen TV's. You can find solutions to the problem. We purchased an entertainment center made to hold a very large 4x3 TV and added shelves over the top of the TV to fill in the unused space.
Right now it seems the sweet spot is around $1,300 for 42" plasma displays. Note that these displays are typically 720P native and convert anything with a higher resolution down to 720P. In my experience, that has not been an issue. After all, the 720P folks like to say that 1080i is really 540P in disguise!
Good luck with whatever you decide to purchase.
I just noticed your comments today, and as always, they are appreciated and insightful.
While it is true that CRT's are the "gold standard" that other displays get compared to, among the the commonly encountered gear at the retailers, I don't see much in the way of high end CRT's. For example, going through the Best Buy online catalog, the CRT's are dominated by standard definition sets with only a handful of hi def CRT's for sale. There are no 40" and above CRT's as they would require a piano mover to get to the house and in the living room.
In the past, plasmas definitely looked better than the LCD's in terms of contrast, viewing angle, and fast action. The latest crop of LCD's has really caught up, and some of them look as good as a plasma to me, although this is clearly subjective. The Samsung in particular, in two different store displays, stood out for being particularly vibrant, and sharp compared to the surrounding sets. I was very unimpressed with several other models, and the off brands clearly looked subpar to me when studied closely.
You're right about the fast motion as the cheaper LCD's definitely pixelate and fall apart on these demanding action sequences.
I'd love to buy a larger set. While cost is one consideration, the more important one is the built in cabinetry. I would literally have to rebuild the entire room to accommodate anything bigger than a 26". Even then, the cabinet only has an internal height of 19.5" so most will not fit. It was originally intended for a 19" CRT back in the 70's so this is already pushing it. It's a rather unique room with not too many electronics makeover possibilities that don't involve a sledgehammer. If I'm disappointed, at least I didn't have to do major construction to get to that point!
So far, I don't see a humongous advantage to 1080i over 720p. On a screen of 26" from several feet away I'm sure I won't notice the difference anyway.
Post a Comment
<< Home